Chargesheet against Kappan is highly disturbing: Justice Kolse Patil  

Justice B G Kolse Patil,

By Muslim Mirror Staff

Mumbai:  As Journalist Siddiqui Kappan completes 365 days in jail on alleged “fabricated charges, Movement Against UAPA and Other Repressive laws (MURL) Chairperson and former Bombay High Court judge, Justice B G Kolse Patil on Tuesday said the charge sheet filed by Uttar Pradesh STF against Kappan is highly disturbing and it goes against the Supreme Court’s efforts to read the sedition law and prevent its misuse.


In a press statement, Justice Patil said in the wake of recent observations of the apex court, the 5,000-page chargesheet filed by the UP Special Task Force in the Kappan case is a highly disturbing document.  Former high court judge pointed out that during a preliminary hearing on a bunch of petitions challenging the sedition law, the Chief Justice of India, N V Ramana, expressed concern over the misuse of the law and the lack of accountability of executive agencies. The Supreme Court’s stance reinforced growing criticism that the colonial-era law was being misused by the state to curb citizens’ freedom, including freedom of expression.

In recent times, the Court has been consistently barring sedition, citing the rigor in the enforcement of the archaic law and the lack of due process. This has pointed to a low conviction rate in these cases, which have shown a significant increase since the year 2016, according to the NCRB data, sedition cases, and those under the stringent Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act saw a rise in 2019, but only 3% of sedition cases led to convictions, he added.

In this backdrop, the 5,000-page chargesheet against journalist Kappan only corroborates the many apprehensions and concerns that have been expressed by civil liberties groups and supported by the apex court. The chargesheet lays out strange allegations against Kappan, who was arrested a year ago, when he was on his way to Hathras in UP to report on the murder of a Dalit woman.

Kappan was booked under the stringent UAPA, and also charged with sedition (Section 124A of IPC). He has been accused of conspiring to incite unrest and riots – the chargesheet claims that Kappan did not write as a “responsible” journalist, “reports only and only to incite Muslims”, and of Maoists and communists and expressed sympathy with It. They have presented volumes of 36 articles written by Kappan in Malayalam – on anti-CAA protests, riots in northeast Delhi, Nizamuddin Markaz gathering during Covid – as evidence. The STF has attached a case diary note, discussing an article written by Kappan during the anti-CAA protests at Aligarh Muslim University, saying, “In the writing, Muslims are portrayed as victims. (Who were beaten up by the police and were asked to go to Pakistan).

Kappan has also been accused of serving as a “think tank” of what they call “Popular Front of India (PFI)”. These “accusations” are unthinkable, unbearable, and too fictitious to think that they might constitute treason. Clearly, the UP STF is attempting a new definition of crime, in which the government grades any dissent and criticism.

The chargesheet against Kappan is a highly disturbing document that goes against the Supreme Court’s efforts to read the sedition law and prevent its misuse. This creates much of the fear that has been highlighted by the court – “executive agencies severely limit individual liberties and criminalize dissent by using a vaguely worded law”.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here