Offensive remarks on Prophet: BJP action against its spokespersons placatory, taken following threats from external powers: Cong


‘MEA calling BJP spokespersons “fringe elements”  a joke

By Abdul Bari Masoud

New Delhi: The Congress on Sunday took a swipe at BJP’s “muscular posturing”  after the saffron party acted against two of its spokespersons over their offending words against Prophet Muhammad following “threats from external powers”. It also said the Ministry of External Affairs calling BJP official spokespersons “fringe elements” is a joke.

Following a strong reaction in the Arab world coupled with summoning of Indian envoy  by  Qatar’s foreign ministry, the BJP was compelled to suspend  its national spokesperson Nupur Sharma and expelled its Delhi media head Naveen Kumar Jindal who made  derogatory remarks against the last prophet of Islam a week ago.

Congress general secretary and chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala accused the BJP of pushing India into a “dark age of religious polarisation to subserve its parochial political agenda in the short term”. In a statement, Congress’ communication chief said, “The placatory expulsion of two key members and spokespersons of the BJP from its primary membership, done obviously under duress of threats from external powers, exposes the much touted ‘muscular posturing’ and positioning of the BJP and the Modi government.”

“Is the BJP sincere in the course of correcting? Is the BJP trying to atone for its immeasurable sins or is it more chameleon-like posturing?” he asked.

Congress leader and former Union Minister Jairam Ramesh said the Ministry of External Affairs calling BJP spokespersons “fringe elements” is a joke. Ramesh tweeted: “BJP has suspended two spokespersons after protests by Qatar government. This is what Americans call a good cop-bad cop routine. First, get your people to be obnoxious. Then act against them under pressure, to appear moderate. MEA calling BJP spokespersons ‘fringe elements’ is a joke!”.

The BJP spokespersons’ comments gained international notice, prompting Qatar’s foreign ministry to call Indian Ambassador Deepak Mittal and deliver an official note expressing “complete rejection and condemnation” of a BJP leader’s outrageous comments against Prophet Muhammad.

“The ambassador conveyed that the tweets do not, in any manner, reflect the views of the Government of India. These are the views of fringe elements,” a spokesperson of the Indian Embassy in Qatar said.

On the other hand, Congress leader Shashi Tharoor said this fire must be doused as it is now gripping NRIs too. The former Union minister said in a tweet in Hindi:  “The way the BJP has adopted the phrase ‘Ghar Phoonk Tamasha Dekhna’ (making a spectacle after setting the house on fire), the head of every secular citizen of the country has bowed in shame. Now even non-resident Indians are coming under the grip of this fire. This fire should be doused immediately.”

The Qatari action is seen as a big embarrassment for the Modi government as the Vice President of India Venkaiah Naidu is in the Gulf nations on an official trip.

In response to Muslim organisations’ protests, the BJP issued a statement intended at assuaging minorities’ concerns and distancing itself from these individuals, claiming that it respects all religions and firmly condemns insults to religious personalities.

Surjewala said that a short statement by the BJP is unlikely to heal the millions of wounds inflicted on the ethos of Indian-ness.  “Will the bulldozing of India’s soul, its ethos and its all-encompassing humanity by the bulldozer of hatred finally stop? Will the mob-lynching of our constitutional ethos cease? Is repentance by the BJP and its leadership possible?” he asked.

As a result, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians as also SCs, STs and OBCs have had to face the wrath of lumpen elements backed by State power, he alleged, adding that this cannot be the central theme of any political party.

“The BJP and its shenanigans have repeatedly and by design insulted India’s centuries old civilisational ethos of ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam’ by constantly pitting one community and religion against another to polarise, to divide and to spread hatred,” Surjewala said.

“None less than the Prime Minister and the BJP Chief Ministers, of the ilk of Adityanath, have introduced a new political vocabulary of State sponsored division of society, i.e. ‘Shamshan-Kabristan’, ’80 versus 20′, ‘bulldozer’,” and “ Garmai nikalana( make submissive) ,  he said, adding that the language of politics during elections no longer centres around phrases like development, employment, progress, education, agriculture, irrigation, electricity, trade and business and infrastructure.

Meanwhile, former Rajya Sabha parliamentarian and BJP leader Subramanian Swami took on the Modi government after it succumbed to the pressure of ‘tiny Qatar’.  He tweeted: During Modi govt’s 8 years, Bharat Mata had to hang her head in shame because we crawled before the Chinese on Ladakh, knelt before the Russians, meowed before the Americans in QUAD. But we did shastangam dandawat before the tiny Qatar. That was depravity of our foreign policy.

Also read-


  1. BJP and its 56 inch leader did’ shastangam dandawat before the tiny Qatar’ as described by its own leader
    Subramanian Swami. Hope BJP and RSS leaders will learn a lesson from this and work for the interest of the country. Raking up false bogy of temples with the help of some courts won’t bring any poltical dividends.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories

Nupur Sharma controversy: SC transfers all FIRs against journalist Navika Kumar to Delhi

NEW DLEHI : The Supreme Court on Friday directed that FIRs registered against Times Now journalist Navika Kumar, in connection with derogatory remarks made...

Prophet row: Nupur Sharma files new application in Supreme Court

New Delhi : Suspended BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma has once again moved the Supreme Court, seeking stay on her arrest in the nine FIRs...

Two parameters to judge two religious controversies in India   

By Syed Ali Mujtaba In India, two back to back two religious controversies are raging on. First, the adverse remarks made by the BJP office-bearer...

Three held in UP for threatening Nupur Sharma’s supporter

Moradabad : Three persons have been arrested for allegedly threatening a supporter of former BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma in this Uttar Pradesh district. The complainant...
By Asad Mirza Last week, veteran Dutch anti-Islam politician Geert Wilders vowed to be Prime Minister of the Netherlands eventually, following an election in which his party won the most seats. Wilders vowed on X: “I will be prime minister.” In a...
PANAJI : Tension prevailed in some parts of Goa after some yet to be identified persons allegedly posted defamatory messages on social media which hurt the sentiments of the Muslim community. Muslim organisations have filed police complaints in Panaji, Margao,...
By Mohd. Ziyaullah Khan, Nagpur In recent years, India has witnessed a concerning surge in hate speech and Islamophobia, particularly within states governed by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). This unsettling trend, highlighted  In a report by Hindutva Watch based...
By Muslim Mirror Staff Mohit Yadav, a bus conductor hailing from Mainpuri and formerly employed by Uttar Pradesh Roadways, tragically took his own life by leaping in front of a train on Monday. This distressing act followed his dismissal, stemming...
ISTANBUL : France plans to ban the abaya, a long loose-fitting overgarment worn by some Muslim women, on school grounds, the country's education minister said on Sunday. Gabriel Attal told broadcaster TF1 that the government intends to convey "clear rules"...