Tablighi Jamaat case : SC asks Modi government to use its powers against ‘fake news’

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday expressed strong displeasure on Centre’s affidavit in a case related to media reporting on a Tablighi Jamaat congregation during the onset of Covid-19 pandemic.

The top court asked the Centre “to consider evolving a mechanism to address issues with content on TV, or else, the court may entrust it to an outside agency”.

A bench headed by Chief Justice S.A. Bobde told Solicitor General Tushar Mehta that the court is not happy with Centre’s affidavit in the matter, as it skirts what powers government has under the Cable TV Network Act to hear such complaints.

The bench asked the Centre to specify how Cable TV Network Act can be used to control the content of Cable TV network.

“Your affidavit is silent on it. The other issue, what steps you can take to deal with such complaints.

“The mechanism — your affidavit is silent on it. Please put all these in your amended affidavit. You (the Centre) have the power under the Act,” added the bench.

The Chief Justice told the Centre why should the court refer to NBSA (News Broadcasters Association), and others, when the Centre has the authority to look into it.

“If it does not exist, then you create an authority, or else we will hand it over to an outside agency,” added the Chief Justice.

The top court has asked the Centre to inform it what mechanism is available under the Cable TV Network (Regulation) Act and what action can be taken against fake news in three weeks.

In August, the Supreme Court, during the hearing of the plea by Jamiat Ulema-i-Hind, which cited the demonising of the minority in connection with the Tablighi Jamaat congregation by various media organisations, had said the governments do not act till we direct them to.

The top court had observed “We have seen from our experience that governments do not act until we direct them to.” The Chief Justice added he is not criticising Mehta but the government does not act until we direct. “That is why this system is here,” added the bench.

The top court had suggested making National Broadcasters Association (NBA) a party in this plea. The Press Council of India (PCI) counsel had contended before the bench it has taken cognizance of 50 instances of false reporting.

The counsel for NBA said it had received around 100 complaints.

The top court noted that it would need assistance from expert bodies on this issue and sought reports from NBA and PCI. Jamiat’s counsel had contended these bodies merely play an advisory role and if there is any action then the government can only take it.

The pleas filed through advocate Ejaz Maqbool said: “By communalising the issue and demonising the entire Muslim community, the actions of the media pose a serious threat to the life and liberty of Muslims across the country. The demonisation is also an infringement of the right to live with dignity which is also covered under Article 21 of the Constitution.”


Also read-


  1. SC can also use power of judgement. When a news is proved false. Aggrieved party or NGO or any individual citizen will go to supreme court direct and Supreme court will give exemplary punishment.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories

Karnataka: Sudhir Chaudhary, Aaj Tak booked for fake news on minorities’ scheme

Bengaluru : The Karnataka Police have registered an FIR against a Hindi news channel and its Consulting Editor on allegations of spreading misinformation about...

‘9 saal 9 sawaal’: Congress raises questions as Modi govt completes 9 yrs

NEW DELHI : The Congress on Friday asked nine questions to Prime Minister Narendra Modi ahead of his government completing nine years in power...

Mallikarjun Kharge gives Modi govt an ‘F for Fail’ on education front

NEW DELHI : Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge on Sunday alleged that the Central government has failed in the education front and students cannot read...

Misinformation is more contagious than the virus: Zafrin Chowdhury,  UNICEF Communication Chief 

By Abdul Bari Masoud Dehradun: UNICEF is striving to combat the threat of fake news by holding Critical Appraisal Skills (CAS) workshops for working journalists....
Varanasi : The Varanasi court on Thursday granted 10 more days to the ASI to complete the Gyanvapi survey and submit report, said Hindu side counsel Madan Mohan Yadav. The ASI had sought three weeks’ time to submit the report,...
Muzaffarnagar : Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, a Muslim body, has raised objections to a recent fashion show held in a local college where participants walked down the ramp wearing burqas. The convener of Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind in Muzaffarnagar, Maulana Mukarram Qasmi, in a...
Srinagar : National Conference (NC) president Farooq Abdullah on Wednesday expressed concern over what he called the “legitimisation of discrimination” against Muslims across the country. “Some policies and actions pursued in various states across the country are providing political patronage...
Mumbai : Under the leadership of former MP Husain Dalwai, a delegation of the Maulana Azad Vichar Munch presented a memorandum to the Governor of Maharashtra, Mr. Ramesh Bais, discussing issues regarding the education, reservation, and protection of the...
Ahmedabad : The Gujarat High Court on Tuesday dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) seeking a ban on the use of loudspeakers for azaan or the Islamic call to prayer at mosques, terming the plea as “wholly misconceived.” A division...