Amnesty released new investigative briefing on February Delhi violence
By Abdul Bari Masoud
New Delhi: Releasing new investigative briefing, global human rights defender, the Amnesty Intentional India on Friday said that the Delhi police continue to enjoy impunity despite incriminating evidence of its personnel were complicit and an active participant in February North East Delhi anti-Muslim violence.
It highlighted that in the last six months not a single investigation has been opened into the human rights violations committed by the Delhi police – before, during and after the violence, while many innocent have been framed for the valence by the police. Demanding that Delhi police impunity must end now, the Amnesty called on the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs to initiate a prompt, thorough, independent and impartial investigation into all allegations of human rights violations by law enforcement officials including excessive use of force, torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, failure to protect the survivors and other individuals from attacks by far-right groups, and the unlawful use of firearms.
The riots in North-East district of Delhi between 23 and 29 February 2020 claimed the lives of more than 50 people, majority of whom were Muslims and injured more than 500.
After speaking to 50 riots survivors, eye witnesses, lawyers, doctors, human rights activists and retired police officers and analysing several user-generated videos, the new Amnesty International India field investigation has documented a disturbing pattern of grave human rights violations committed by the Delhi police during the riots. These violations include police officers indulging in violence with the rioters; torturing in custody; using excessive force on protesters; dismantling sites of peaceful protests and; being mute bystanders as rioters wreaked havoc.
After releasing the 20-page New Investigative Brief, Avinash Kumar, Executive Director of Amnesty International India, said the first step towards ensuring justice to riot victims is to end impunity of Delhi police as its complicity is now well documented.
“Six months on, there has not been even a single investigation into the role of the Delhi police. This ongoing state-sponsored impunity sends the message that the law enforcement officials can commit grave human rights violations and evade accountability. That they are a law unto themselves,” he added.
The investigative briefing documents the build-up to the riots, providing a timeline of police brutality in university campuses and the hateful speeches made by political leaders including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader, Kapil Mishra in Delhi. It further documents the Delhi police’s inadequate response in preventing the riots and its active participation in the violence. This includes the denial of medical services to victims, failure to rescue them, excessive and arbitrary use of force on protesters and differential treatment of assemblies. The briefing then demonstrates a pattern of torture and ill-treatment meted out on riot survivors and detainees by the Delhi police after the violence, followed by the harassment and intimidation of survivors and peaceful protesters.
To verify the evidence of human rights violations in the user-generated social media videos during the riots, Amnesty International India collaborated with Amnesty International’s Crisis Evidence Lab. The Lab uses cutting-edge open-source and digital investigation tools to corroborate and analyse serious human rights violations. It authenticated these videos by verifying the time, date and location of the videos. In addition, Amnesty International India visited the locations where the videos were shot and interviewed the eyewitnesses and survivors.
In one of the several videos analysed by Amnesty International’s Crisis Evidence Lab, Delhi police officers can be seen kicking and hitting a group of five wounded men on 24 February, poking them with rifles and asking them to sing the Indian National Anthem. After the video was shot, the men were detained by the police. Amnesty International India analysed the video footage and spoke to the mother of 26-year-old Faizan, one of the men in the video.
Police’s Complicity and Failure
Kismatun, Faizan’s mother, told Amnesty International India that she had seen the video several times but did not realise until much later that her son was also there in the video.
“I went to the police station along with my son’s photograph. I showed them his photograph and asked if he was there and they said yes. I asked them if they would let me see him and if they would let him go. The policeman said no. But I waited there till 1 o’clock in the night,” she said.
Faizan was detained by the police for close to 36 hours without any charge. He was handed over to his mother after his condition deteriorated. The police refused to give any paperwork to the family to show that he had been detained.
According to Shahida, a riot survivor, “We called the 100-emergency number multiple times but there was no answer. When they did answer, they kept saying, ‘you want Azaadi (freedom)? Here Take azaadi (freedom) now”.
Another victim Bhure Khan said:
“They were raising slogans of ‘Jai Shri Ram’ (Hail Lord Rama). First they set my car and motorcycle on fire. My brother was hit by a stone. We realised that the police were hand in glove with the rioters so I told my family that it is best to leave everything and run”.
“75% of the cases that we handled were firearm injuries. Many had pellet injuries, some had bullet injuries. Some were crushed. There were a few whose legs had been torn apart. There were many cases like that,” said Dr M A Anwar, Director Al Hind Hospital
The ruthless treatment of the heavily injured men by the Delhi police violates the international human rights standards that allow for force to be used only as a last resort, as much necessary to achieve the objective of such use and proportional to that objective. It also violates Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), to which India is a state party.
Delhi police also violated the domestic law by not following the due procedure as set out in Indian laws. In 1997, the Supreme Court of India in the case of D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal also laid down a set of guidelines to prevent custodial abuse and torture that have since been incorporated in the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). These guidelines and various sections of the CrPC call for the preparation of an arrest memo with the date and time of arrest signed by the arrested person and an independent witness. It also states that a family member should be informed of the person’s arrest along with their place of detention and that the arrested persons must be medically examined after being taken into custody. It also requires the police to produce every arrested person before a magistrate within 24 hours.
The report also analysed the role played by BJP politicians who made hate speeches in the build-up to the riots. To illustrate, on 23 February, BJP leader Kapil Mishra, while leading a rally against the peaceful protests in Jaffrabad in North-East Delhi, gave the Delhi police a live-streamed three-day ultimatum to remove the protesters. His speech was immediately followed by widespread violence. However, none of the political leaders have been prosecuted so far.
“Amnesty International India calls on the Ministry of Home Affairs to conduct a prompt, thorough, transparent, independent and impartial investigation into all allegations of human rights violations committed by Delhi police and the hate speeches made by political leaders. Delhi has witnessed two major communal violence incidents across a period of four decades – the 2020 riots and the 1984 Sikh massacre. A common link between both the incidents is the human rights violations committed by the Delhi police.
Avinash Kumar said the repetition of such violations point towards a climate of impunity. This impunity sends the message to the politicians and police who advocate for violence in their speeches and fail to prevent the violence that follows that they can get away with committing such grave human rights violations. This impunity needs to and must end in order to bring justice to the victims and their family members.”