Is Indian state proxying for the Hindutva project of militarization of the majority?

Members of RSS, right wing organisation supported by ruling BJP party

By Prof.Shamsul Islam

Presently, the Indian defence paraphernalia is ranked as the fourth mightiest army in the world after USA, Russia and China with Japan at the fifth place. It has approximately 3,544,000 on roll, 1,444,000 being on active duty with 2,100,000 as reserve personnel.[i] It is credited with innumerable military operations of glory like Bangladesh War 1971, Kargil War 1999, surgical strikes in Pakistan occupied Kashmir 2019 etc. Indian Army rendered direct help to the Sri Lankan State in suppressing the LTTE; the Tamilian rebels (1987-90) and has been immensely contributing to the UN peace-keeping military operations in different parts of the world numbering more than 43. According to the Indian Army website “India is ranked, as the third largest troop contributor to the UN”[ii] contributing 2, 00,000 Indian troops.[iii]



However, it is sad that when India continues to witness a devastation and mayhem only comparable to the 1947 Partition; the 4th mightiest army in the world has rendered help which cannot be described even as cosmetic. Approximately, last two months of the abrupt lock-down have proved decisively that the Indian State completely betrayed the working class and poor Indians. In absence of jobs, food, shelter, transport and health care millions of them were left to suffer horrible times and tragedies. The stories are so horrendous that the term gut-wrenching would be highly under-statement to describe the prevalent hunger, maiming and killings of migratory workers (it is a kind of racism that workers belonging to India if go to work in different parts of the country are described as migratory workers. This term is not used for those who join high-profile jobs or politicians) in almost all parts of the country. The three wings of the Indian armed forces; the army, air force and navy have finest medical, transport and communication paraphernalia.

It is puzzling that all these were kept locked-down in face of the rampaging Covid-19 pandemic when India was in dire need of doctors, hospitals, vehicles, airplanes and high quality professional communication facilities. All major cities of India have the most modern military hospitals which if opened for Covid-19 patients would have greatly lessened the unbearable pressure on the civil health services. If a small number of military doctors and nursing staff were deputed in critical areas, the sufferings and fatalities would have been lessened.

The lock-down showed how migratory workers suffered and are suffering while trying to reach to their native places; road, rail services almost incapable of help. The mighty transport capacity available with the army would have made a real difference. Likewise, with a centralized and most modern surveillance system of the armed forces and its own satellites in the space (using which India was able to identify terrorist centres in Pakistan and destroyed the same celebrated as ‘surgical strikes’) the devastated multitudes in millions which included pregnant women, children, old and disabled persons, walking on roads and rail tracks (many of them getting killed while undertaking these risky journeys) would have been identified and picked up in army vehicles or airplanes.

It intervened only to shower flower petals on the hospitals and army/navy/air force bands playing outside hospitals which were treating the Covid-19 patients (despite warning from the medical fraternity that this shower of flowers may be a serious cause of spreading the dreaded virus and a law that hospital areas are ‘no noise’ areas). It was ostensibly done with a noble objective to honour the ‘warriors’ against the Covid-19. Even a cosmetic intervention should have meant deputing a small number of medical and Para-medical staff in at least Red Zones. In fact, many countries of the world including African countries armed forces were deployed to fight the pandemic which continue to play great pro-active role in this fight.[iv]


It is puzzling that the Indian armed forces remaining insulated during the times of Covid-19 came out with a plan of employing Indians for a 3-year voluntary ‘tour of duty’.[v] According to a release from the Indian Army,

“The proposal is a shift from the concept of permanent service/job in the Armed Forces, towards ‘internship’/temporary experience for three years. It is for youth who “do not want to make defence services their permanent vocation, but still want to experience the thrill and adventure of military professionalism”.

Explaining the rationale behind this innovative scheme the note read that it was to tap the “resurgence of nationalism and patriotism” amongst Indian youth and help reduce the unemployment in India. The proposal also envisages that the earnings of these three years could be made tax-free and all those who would be part of ‘tour of duty’ could be given preference in public sector jobs as well as post-graduate courses. The note also stressed the fact that it would help to channelize the youth energy into positive utilization of their potential and that “rigorous military training and habits inculcated will lead to healthy citizenry”.[vi]

This announcement proposing a policy decision, unheard and never debated in Parliament or at the ministry of defence level, about new mode and tenure of recruitment in the Indian Army was not made public by the defence minister, Rajnath Singh or Chief of Defence Staff of India, General Bipin Rawat but through a press-note of the Army. Army spokesperson Colonel Aman Anand confirmed that such a proposal was being discussed. The opposition political parties and media did not bother to react to this proposal which may prove to be a defining moment for future of democratic-secular India.

The above note during Covid-19 times raises many important questions, the answers to which have to be found to determine the future course of democratic-secular Indian polity. The loud mouthed claim that 3-year voluntary ‘tour of duty’ would help reducing unemployment is laughable. The claim gives the impression that out of millions and millions of unemployed Indian youth few millions are going to be absorbed under this scheme. How Indian Army is helping to reduce unemployment can be known by the fact that it plans to reduce force strength by cutting 1.5 lakh jobs. In some sections the reduction is going to be as high as 20%.[vii]


Justifying the scheme Army note said that it was in response to the “resurgence of nationalism and patriotism” and “rigorous military training and habits inculcated will lead to healthy citizenry”. Thus nationalism, patriotism and healthy citizenry are being equated with the Army training. Such slogans world generally heard during the World War II and presently hears in totalitarian states like North Korea and Zionist Israel.


The fact is that such a scheme has been part of the old Hindutva project namely ‘Militarize Hindu Society’ zealously promoted by leaders of Hindu Mahasabha and RSS. The well-known Italian researcher of Indian politics, Marzia Casolari has done pioneering work in tracing the fraternal links between the Hindu Mahasabha and RSS founders on the one hand and Fascism and Nazism which stood for militarization of societies. According to her pioneer work relying on the primary sources of the documents of the prominent Hindu nationalists, one of the aspects of Fascism which appealed most to the Hindu nationalists was militarization of society. Balakrishna Shivram Moonje, a mentor of the RSS founder, Keshav Baliram Hedgewar on his return from the Round Table Conference, Moonje regarded as the Dharmveer (Brave of the religion) made a tour of Italy (February-March 1931). There he visited some important military schools (Military College, the Central Military School of Physical Education, the Fascist Academy of Physical Education), highlight of the visit being a meeting with Mussolini.

Moonje praised the militarization project of Mussolini and planned to put into practice in India. He wrote:

“India and particularly Hindu India needs some such institution for the military regeneration of the Hindus: so that the artificial distinction so much emphasized by the British, of martial and non-martial classes amongst the Hindus, may disappear…Our institution of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh of Nagpur under Hedgewar is of this kind, though quite independently conceived. I will spend the rest of my life in developing and extending this Institution of Hedgewar all throughout Maharashtra and other provinces.”[viii]

As soon as he reached Pune, he gave an interview to ‘The Mahratta’. Regarding the military reorganization of the Hindu community, he stressed the necessity      to      ‘Indianise’      the       army and expressed the hope that conscription would become compulsory and   an   Indian   would   be    put    in-charge    of    the defence ministry. He finally made a clear reference to the Italian and German examples in his diary:

“In fact, leaders should imitate the youth movements of Germany and the Balilla and Fascist organisations of Italy. I think they are eminently suited for introduction in India, adapting them to suit the special conditions. I have been very much impressed by these movements and I have seen their activities with my own eyes in all details.”

According to Moonje’s diary on March 31, 1934, he himself, Hedgewar and Laloo Gokhale had a meeting, the subject of which was again the military organisation of the Hindus, along the Italian and German lines. Moonje told the gathering,

“I have thought out a scheme based on the Hindu Dharm Shashtra which provides for the standardization of Hinduism throughout India… But the point is that this ideal cannot be brought to effect unless we have our own swaraj with a Hindu as a dictator like Shivaji of old or Mussolini or Hitler of the present day Italy or Germany… But this does not mean that we have to sit with folded hands until (sic) some such dictator arises in India. We should formulate a scientific scheme and carry on propaganda for it…”

According to Marzia, Moonje publicly admitted that his idea of militarily reorganizing Hindu society was inspired by the “military training schools of England, France, Germany and Italy.”

Moonje’s ‘Preface to the Scheme of the Central Hindu Military Society and its Military School’ which he circulated among influential personalities, out rightly says:

“This training is meant for qualifying and fitting our boys for the game of killing masses of men with the ambition of winning victory with the best possible causalities (sic) of dead and wounded while causing the utmost possible to the adversary.”

It is not to be missed here that what Moonje meant by ‘adversary’ was not the external enemy, the British, but ‘historical’ internal enemy, the Muslims. In fact, this School was inaugurated by then Governor of Bombay State, Sir Roger Lumley. Moreover, this School helped the British in supplying Hindu youth for the World War II. This military school was financed by two old stooges of the British; the Bhonsles and Scindias. Moonje gave a call to ‘militarize the Hindu society’.


Vinayak Damodar Savarkar went to the extent of organizing more than 100 recruitment camps for Hindus in the British Army when Netaji Subhash Chander Bose was trying to liberate India militarily from abroad. This was part of Savarkar’s strategy to militarize Hindus of India. Savarkar called upon Hindus “to flood the [British] army, the navy and the aerial forces with millions of Hindu warriors with Hindu Sanghatanist hearts” and assured them that if Hindus recruited in the British armed forces,

“our Hindu nation is bound to emerge far more powerful, consolidated and situated in an incomparably more advantageous position to face issues after the war— whether it be an internal anti-Hindu Civil War or a constitutional crisis or an armed revolution.”[ix]


RSS since its inception (1925) has been working for one main agenda; cleansing of Muslims and Christians from India. Hedgewar, the founder of RSS left Congress because freedom struggle under the leadership of Congress stood for an-all inclusive India in which Muslims would be part of nation. Hedgewar’s successor , Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar in his book, We or Our Nationhood Defined (1939) eulogizing the cleansing of Jews by Hitler made it clear that RSS would like to emulate it:

“German Race pride has now become the topic of the day. To keep up the purity of the Race and its culture, Germany shocked the world by her purging the country of the Semitic Races—the Jews. Race pride at its highest has been manifested here. Germany has also shown how well-nigh impossible it is for Races and cultures, having differences going to the root, to be assimilated into one united whole, a good lesson for us in Hindusthan to learn and profit by.” [x]

There was no respite in hatred towards Muslims and Christians even after the birth of independent India. Golwalkar, a Guru of Hate penned a chapter titled ‘Internal Threats’ to India. It appeared in the holy book for the RSS cadres, Bunch of Thoughts, the compilation of the writings of MS Golwalkar. , the ideologue of the RSS, has a long chapter titled, ‘Internal Threats’ in which the Muslims and Christians are described as threats number one and two respectively. The Communists get the honour of being ‘Internal Threat’ number three.[xi]

With Modi’s coming to power in 2014 the Hindutva juggernaut started running amok and the RSS leaders brazenly declared that by 2021 India would be cleansed of Muslims and Christians.[xii] An aggressive campaign in the name of ‘love-jihad’, ‘ghar-wapsi’ and cow started in which Muslims and Christians were lynched. Perturbed by this Hindutva frenzy in less than a year of Modi’s rule that one of the most decorated cops of India, Julio Ribeiro, former ambassador to Romania and recipient of the Padma Bhushan, a prominent national award wrote on March 17, 2015:

“Today, in my 86th year, I feel threatened, not wanted, reduced to a stranger in my own country. ..I am not an Indian anymore, at least in the eyes of the proponents of the Hindu Rashtra. Is it coincidence or a well-thought-out plan that the systematic targeting of a small and peaceful community should begin only after the BJP government of Narendra Modi came to power last May? It is tragic that these extremists [Hindutva zealots] have been emboldened beyond permissible limits by an atmosphere of hate and distrust. The Christian population, a mere 2 per cent of the total populace, has been subjected to a series of well-directed body blows. If these extremists later turn their attention to Muslims, which seems to be their goal, they will invite consequences that this writer dreads to imagine.”[xiii]


Julio Ribeiro was right when he wrote that cleansing of Muslims was the goal of RSS cadres. This was corroborated by none other but a very senior RSS ideologue and Governor of Tripura Tathagata Roy.  On June 18, 2017, this RSS icon quoting another icon of RSS, Syama Prasad wrote:

“Syama Prasad Mookerjee wrote in his diary on 10/1/1946: ‘The Hindu-Muslim problem won’t b solved without a Civil War’. So much like Lincoln!”

Mind it; it was not some street ruffian who was baying for civil war against Muslims of India but one of the occupiers of the highest constitutional office. When criticized for this take of his he refused to withdraw the comment saying that he was only quoting SP Mookerjee. Incidentally, Mookerjee continues to be a great icon for RSS. Moreover, Modi government continued patronizing him as no explanation was sought from him.[xiv]


According to international media reports RSS has been building a militant alliance with fascist Buddhist organization in the South Asia against Muslims and Christians. The New York Times in an editorial titled ‘Deadly Alliances Against Muslims’ dated October 15, 2014 disclosed sensational facts in this regard.[xv]


It was no coincidence that controversial renowned yoga guru, a Hindutva saint, one of the richest men in India and darling of the RSS-BJP rulers, Baba Ramdev decided to start a private security agency under his Patanjali Yogpeeth Trust. It announced enlisting,

“Guards from its 11 lakh yoga centres across India. Called Parakram Suraksha Private Ltd., the company will provide employment to the young and protect the country’s assets, SK Tijarawala, spokesperson of Patanjali Yogpeeth… There is a need for 50 lakh guards in India, he said”.[xvi]

Why Ramdev ventured into security business is not difficult to understand. He has been brand ambassador of RSS preached masculine Hindu nationalism. In March 1916 he gave the war-cry for beheading all those who refused to chant ‘Bharat Mata ki Jai’[xvii]

It is no ordinary security agency. Ramdev started it to “provide employment to the young and protect the country’s assets”. It is alleged to be a Hindu nationalist venture. With such outlets RSS and other Hindutva organizations did not need to organize surreptitious arms training camps. Enroll from any of the 11 lakh yoga centres of Ramdev and get training in all kinds of arms. Unfortunately, there has been no state or non-state scrutiny of such Hindutva ventures. It would be a sad day for democratic-secular Indian polity if the Indian army actually joins this project of militarization of the majority community, facilitating directly or indirectly the Hindutva organizations’ long hanging project of civil war against the largest minority of India. It is crucial to know that Hindutva love for religious strife suits the international enemies of India too. It represents another serious threat to the existing democratic polity of India. In case, RSS-BJP regime loses power such cadres trained in sophisticated arms may be used not to let the democratic process continue.


Link for some of S. Islam’s writings in English, Hindi, Urdu, Marathi, Malayalam, Kannada, Bengali, Punjabi, Gujarati and video interviews/debates:

Facebook: shamsul

Twitter: @shamsforjustice










[viii] Casolari, Marzia, ‘Hindutva’s Foreign Tie-up in the 1930’s: Archival Evidence’, The Economic and Political Weekly, January 22, 2000, pp. 218-228. All other quotes on Moonje are from this article.

[ix] Cited in Savarkar, V. D., Samagra Savarkar Wangmaya: Hindu Rashtra Darshan, vol. 6, Maharashtra Prantik Hindusabha, Poona, 1963, pp. 461.


[x] MS Golwalkar, We Or Our Nationhood Defined, Bharat Publications, Nagpur, 1939, p. 35.


[xi] Golwalkar, MS, Bunch of Thoughts, Saitya Sindhu Prakashana, 1966, Bangalore,  pp. 177-95.


[xii] ‘We will free India of Muslims and Christians by 2021’ Mail Today, Delhi, December 19, 2014



[xv] &






  1. Wherever muslims emerged as majority, they have formed an Islamic state.. Hence, muslims have no moral rights to talk against Hindu Rashtra.

    • muslim ruled india by 800 years still india is secular country and bjp & rss ruled only eight years they are trying to make india is a hindu rashtra so u dont have right to give lecture to muslim

      • When Mughals rule India, was India a secular country? Are you fool? These cruel Mughal kings have destroyed our great Hindu culture. Force conversion, raping hindu women, destroying temples was their agenda. They were demons came from middle east.

        • Hahaha, how ignorant you are (and petty foolish) to “know” that Mughals came from middle East!!! It show how addled your historical “knowledge” is and how Intellectually handicapped you’re to be so helpless to think critically about information that’s bring piped down your throat…

        • ‘Islamic rule’ for 800 years and according to Hindutva zealots “Force conversion, raping hindu women, destroying temples was their agenda. They were demons…” Despite that, after this ‘Islamic’ rule Hindus remained 80% of the population, possessing almost all wealth of the nation, jobs, lands! This ‘Islamic’ rule continued with direct support from the Hindu high castes. After Humayun no Mughal ruler was from a MUslim mother. These ‘Islamic’ rulers hated Indian Muslims but married into high caste Hindus. Thes Hindutva criminals must know that Raja Jay Singh II was the SAMDHEE of Auranzeb; Jay Singh’s daughter was married to him who became Mughal King after Aurangzeb. BTW, if crimes of a ruler have to be connected to his/her religion then what about Ravana? For his crimes all Brahmins have to be punished.

          • You may give few examples of good work done by Mughal kings but it is true that overall, they have destroyed great Hindu culture. We had to struggle for 70 years just to build Ram temple in Ayodhya. And after giving Pakistan & Bangladesh land to muslims, present India land belong to Hindus.
            Now, Hindus want to get their golden days back & hence we want to establish Hindu culture in India.

  2. Very true and basic sense.A country can only be demolished by its majority people and not by its minority people.

  3. In fact Muslims and christains are very easy is not a big task to handle them.
    Sure India is in danger and definetly not bcos of Muslims and christains.
    I can say Muslims and Christians are simply a diversion factor.

  4. mujlims wll be happy in afganista, somlia,pakistan-

    so will hindus be in india.

    let the move begin

    india should have been hindu republic in 1947.

    westen countries want to deport muslims- dont know how to do it. danmark has ban. no masjid allowed. burqa
    mynmaar has deprted mujlims.

  5. We need a military force of around 100 million Hindu men, armed with AK-47s. Then, if/when a Civil War breaks out, the Muslim invaders (who are not even Indian) will be exterminated.

    • Mind you, I am not calling for any action now. But I don’t trust Muslims, as Muslims have killed over 80 million Hindus since 1200 AD.
      From 1200 AD to 1700 AD, Muslims barbarians invaded India’s land, killed 80 million Hindus, and destroyed 40,000 Hindu, Buddhist, and Jain temples.

      Going forward, if Hindus want to survive, Hindus will have to equip themselves with guns and ammunition.
      If Muslims kill one Hindu, Hindus should be able to kill 100 Muslims.

  6. This idioric logic is given by every muslim including the author that Muslim invaders were hood people, and if they wanted to covert all hindus India would not be 80% Hindu majority.

    Remember, Pakistan, Bangladeh Afghanistan were also hindu majority. Today there alomts 95% muslims majority.

    Nearly half of the hindu populations was converted…

    Biggest hypocrites…why cant muslim accept what was wrong…

    Even muslim deny hindu temple destructions by muslim invaders.
    Qurub Minar and Quqatul Islam masjid near it..there is borad that says 100s of hindu, jain and budhist temples were destruted to create the Quwatul Islam Masjid.

    Still they dent it…

    If muslims dont have a probelm with Sharia..why they should have probelm with Hindutva idelogy..

    Hidutva does not says that we should not allow non hindus to build masjids whereas in quran and sharia muslims dont allow the same rights.

    This hypocrit author called Israle Zionist. However the zionist Israel allows muslims to build masjinds and practice their religion.
    The hypocrit author does not critisize Islamic countries that practive Sharia where non muslims especially Hindus have no rights to practice their religion, build temples or even carry photographs of their gods.

    Absolutely biased article ..Favouring his Muslim fraternity

    • Arabs don’t have any talent & hence they request Hindus to join them. Once oil in Arab countries is be finished, these countries are really going to become beggars.

    • This statement of your shows your love for Arab and muslim world..bcos thats where your loyalties lies even if asian mulsims are considered as 3rd or 4th class citizens over there.
      Kicking out hindus will have no impact..let them come here and Indians should kick out all people who consider arab as their ancestors.

      • Arabs are not the ancestors of Muslims in India. Their ancestors were Indians. It’s an undeniable fact. But the things is Indian ancestors of Muslims saw Islam and understood it as the Divine Truth from the Creator of Everything that exists and accepted it wholeheartedly. And that’s how the Reality is. Indian Muslims are grateful to the Indian ancestors, True Sons and Daughters of. India, for having accepted The Divine Truth-Islam. Anyone who denies this historical truth is either completely Ignorant or is a abhorrent bigot.

        • Divine Truth – Islam,

          We understand that your ancestors were raped murdered and tortured and forced to accept islam. Talwar ke dum me app ko salwar pehen ni padi.

          Ab app azaad ho..gahr wapas aajoa..

          Current hindu population is the strongest. They did not convert and fought back the invaders and remained hindus. You were from the weakest lot of hindus who had to convert. That weakness and fear is still there..accept the truth, dont fear..revert back to dharma.

  7. The so called Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh in its website describes introduce itself as an ‘Social organisation’.
    1. Why does the three time banned social organisation need military style weapons training for its members?
    2. Why does the organisation has no proper registration record as per the compulsory guidelines of the Ministry of Home Affairs?
    3. Why the organisation never furnish its finical audit report to the MOH?
    4. Does RSS respect Indian ‘National flag’, ‘National anthem’ and constitution laid down by the Dr.Amebdkar?
    5. Why do RSS is the only organisation has the right to brandish lethal weapons in public which even serving member or retire of the forces has not?
    6. Is this arms are registered under the Arms act?
    7. Why does RSS operates in different names from aborad?
    Jai Hind

  8. muslms should get certain areas for islamic states.muslims should be removed frm hindu areas-
    best solution. muslims unwelcome in christian countries. read about it.

    muslims are bigoted, unable to think- see across the world.

    their contribution to the world- no paintings, music, science.

    across the world they live in own areas- most europeans dont venture into muslim areas,

    see difference in the west. 4 hindu,s in british cabinet. top ceo,s of foreign companies.muslims stuck to beards, skull caps,burqas- halal meat.

    good heavens. even so called educated muslimare dumb,like author.

  9. Sbobet is a trusted gambling site that operates
    to help every fans of online gambling in the world.
    Founded in 2010, it didn’t resign yourself to long for
    Sbobet to become the biggest online site in Asia
    and behind it comes to the amount of betting child support that rotates all week, Sbobet is moreover one of the biggest sites in the world.

    Sbobet is agreed popular, especially accompanied by Asian bettors,
    the defense is that the site has been awarded as the best gambling operator
    for two years in a row. It offers a variant of football betting bearing in mind certainly low margins later than compared to new sites
    in its class.

  10. Thanks for some other informative site. Where else could I get that kind of info written in such an ideal means?
    I’ve a venture that I am simply now operating on,
    and I have been on the glance out for such info.

  11. Mabosbola is an established online casino agent that will provides
    access regarding online casino fans in Indonesia for the best online on line
    casino gambling games. Mabosbola provides for a connecting site by
    giving full access for you fans associated with casino gambling video games to the best on-line casino game supplier sites for example Sbobet or Nova88.
    Started in 2018, Mabosbola has an incredible number of users
    from all over Dalam negri. Every day you can find hundreds of men and
    women connected to the video games offered by Mabosbola.
    Even though this website is nevertheless relatively young, this particular site has been verified to end up being able to supply professional services for every customer
    and obtain an official certificate from PAGCOR.

    The Best Types of On the internet Casino Games
    Not only does it provide total access to numerous types
    of total online casino sport collections, Mabosbola furthermore
    provides quality and international standard video games served by the particular best online casino
    betting providers inside their class. The following are usually a number of the
    provider companies which have collaborated along with Mabosbola in supplying the most effective online casino gambling in Indonesia.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here