There is a pattern to marginalise Muslim community, SC told during Hijab case hearing

NEW DELHI : Senior advocate Dushyant Dave, representing some petitioners challenging the Karnataka High Court judgment on hijab, on Monday told the Supreme Court that there is a pattern to marginalise a community and citing the Pulwama attack, added that only one suicide bombing took place in India, which shows minorities have placed their faith on the country.

Dave submitted before a bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia that more than 10,000 suicide bombings have taken place in Islamic world and this country only faced one suicide bombing in Pulwama, which shows minority communities’ faith in the country.

He added that religion is a very difficult frame of mind to guide the masses and it is leaders who can guide them.

Dave said the whole issue of “love jihad” and now, the prevention of Muslim girls from wearing hijab in educational institutions, reflects a pattern to marginalise the minority community, and Muslim girls wearing hijab cannot hurt anybody’s sentiments and hijab is their identity.

Emphasising the significance of liberal aspect of Indian civilisation, Dave said the country is built on liberal tradition and there is unity in diversity. He submitted that if a Hindu girl asks a Muslim girl wearing hijab “why is she wearing it? And, she talks about her religion. This is really beautiful”.

Dave added that the West has already permitted hijab and the American army has also allowed turbans. He said as one cannot quarrel with right of Sikhs to wear turbans, similarly, one should also have no quarrel with right of Muslim women to wear hijab, and stressed that for centuries, Muslim women have been wearing hijab in countries across the world.

He contended that hijab is important for Muslim women and it is their faith and added that somebody wants to wear tilak, somebody wanting to wear cross, everybody has the right and that is the beauty of social life.

“How would wearing hijab threaten the unity and integrity of the country?” he said. At this, the bench replied that even the Karnataka High Court judgment does not say that and nobody is saying that.

The bench also said the argument here could be self-contradictory, saying the right to wear hijab flows from Article 19 and it can be restricted only under 19(2) only by a statutory law. Dave submitted that fundamental rights, in this case under Article 25, can be exercised anywhere.

The bench said some judgments talk about religious practice inside the religious places. Dave said Article 25 uses the words freely practice, profess, and propagate religion, and a person can exercise fundamental rights anywhere, be it a classroom too.

He said if a Muslim woman thinks that wearing of hijab is conducive for her religion, no authority, or no court can say otherwise.

The hearing on the petitions challenging the Karnataka High Court’s judgement of March 15 upholding ban on hijab in pre-university colleges will continue on Tuesday. — IANS

Also read-


  1. Pakistani women’s football team does not wear burka
    Pakistani school girl children does not wear burka
    In Saudi and Iran women protested against burka.
    The direct decedent’s of prophet Mohd the king of Jordan and his family does not wear burka
    But now the Muslims in India have started the usual anti Hindu propaganda. Let us be reminded hijab was allowed in schools even prior to the protests. But Muslim girls like Muslim funded and supported by PFI wanted to wear burka ( black tents) in school endangered the life of other students hence there was ban on burka not hijab. But see how they bribe judges and make this in to a hinduphobia propaganda. Haha lol. Muslim Nahi naaz ayenge. The hatred Abrahamic religions have for Hindus is amazing.

  2. Everyone saw muskaaan said Allah u bakbar for rights to wear burqa she was not interested in hijab as it was already allowed, stop fooling us with fake hinduphobia propaganda.

  3. Everyone remembers the video of muskaan where she said allah u bakbar with black tent burqa.
    Everyone remembers girls sponsored by PFI standing at the gates of school trying to enter school in a burqa.
    Stop lies and propaganda to show yourself as the victim. Everyone know hijab was already allowed in schools the muslims propagandists wanted to wear the black tent burqa which was denied by the school. Burqa endangers the lives of other children and hence cannot be allowed.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories

SC to hear pleas over constitutionality of sedition law in January

New Delhi : The Supreme Court said on Wednesday that it will hear the batch of petitions challenging the constitutionality of the colonial-era penal...

SC tags Umar Khalid’s plea challenging UAPA with existing petitions against it

New Delhi : The Supreme Court on Friday tagged a writ petition by former JNU scholar and activist Umar Khalid with other existing petitions...

Ex-Maha Minister Nawab Malik’s bail extended by three months

New Delhi : The Supreme Court on Thursday extended for three months its earlier order granting interim bail on medical grounds to former Maharashtra...
11 men sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering 7 Muslims and gang-raping a pregnant Bilkis Bano after being released.

SC hearing arguments against remission granted to convicts in Bilkis Bano case

New Delhi : The Supreme Court on Wednesday commenced hearing rejoinder arguments on behalf of the petitioners, including Bilkis Bano, against the early release...
Kolkata : On Wednesday, Union home minister Amit Shah asserted the Central government will implement the Citizenship (Amendment) Act and no one can stop it. Addressing a big rally here to launch the party’s Lok Sabha campaign, Shah launched a...
New Delhi : The Supreme Court on Wednesday adjourned till January 10 the hearing on the bail plea of former JNU student Umar Khalid in a case lodged under anti-terror law UAPA over his alleged involvement in the conspiracy...
Siddharthnagar : A temple in Uttar Pradesh’s Siddharthnagar district was ‘purified’ with ‘gangajal’ after a visit by a Muslim MLA of the Samajwadi Party. Doomariyaganj MLA Sayeda Khatoon had on Sunday visited the Samay Mata temple at the invitation of...
New Delhi : A court here has acquitted nine accused people of all charges, including rioting, vandalism, and arson, during the 2020 Delhi riots, saying they were entitled to the benefit of the doubt. Additional Sessions Judge Pulastya Pramachala was...
Srinagar : After it faced flak from a section of politicians, the Jammu and Kashmir Police on Tuesday defended booking under UAPA seven university students who had raised objectionable slogans after the Indian cricket team’s in the World Cup...