PM should tell nation how Chinese occupied Indian territory and killed our soldiers : Sonia Gandhi

By Abdul Bari Masoud

New Delhi: Main opposition Congress on Wednesday urged the Prime Minister, Narendra Modi to tell the nation the truth about the  situation at Ladakh’s Galwan Valley where 20 Indian soldiers were killed in violent clashes with Chinese troops on Monday (June 15).

In a video address, Congress president Sonia Gandhi slammed the Modi government for its handling of the Chinese aggression at the LAC.  She posed a pointed question to the PM Modi as the Indian army lost 20 soldiers in the violent clash with the Chinese army.

Asking the PM Modi to reveal the nation “how the Chinese occupied Indian territory,” and the reason behind the fight, Ms Gandhi sought details of the number of soldiers injured and missing.

“The sacrifice of our 20 jawans has shaken the conscience of the nation. I pay my tribute to all those brave soldiers from the core of my heart and pray to the almighty to give their families the strength to face this pain,” she said.

She also urged the prime minister to provide information about the parts of Indian Territory that China has occupied.

Congress president’s   address coincided with the PM’s first-ever statement on the issue since Monday in which he said that India will give “a befitting reply if instigated.”

In a televised address the PM said that “India wants peace, but if instigated, India at all costs is capable of giving an appropriate response.”

Prior to this statement, Modi had been accused by opposition leaders like Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi and former Prime Minister Deve Gowda of staying silent on the month-long border tensions with China and Monday’s killings.

 Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi and former Karnataka chief minister Siddaramaiah took potshots at the PM for maintaining silence over the issue.

Using the twitter handle, former Congress president Rahul Gandhi also posed some pointed questions to the PM.  In his tweet, Rahul killing of soldiers was so painful, then why did the PM take two days to condole the death of our brave soldiers. He also flayed pro-Modi media which blamed the army instead of the Modi government for this fiasco in the Ladakh.

If it was so painful:

  1. Why insult Indian Army by not naming China in your tweet?
  2. Why take 2 days to condole?
  3. Why address rallies as soldiers were being martyred?
  4. Why hide and get the Army blamed by the crony media?
  5. Why make paid-media blame Army instead of GOI?

Meanwhile, former army generals also criticized the government for the border row which resulted in killing of soldiers in big numbers.

If there is one analyst who kept raising an alarm about China, it is Lt Gen (retd) HS Panag. In a no-holds-barred interview to the Hindustan Times, Gen Panag said the killing of 20 soldiers, is the worst in the history of the Indian army.

 Echoing  the similar concerns,  well-known strategic affairs expert, Ajai Shukla  also underlined in his blog that” for the first time since the Kargil intrusions of 1999, Indian territory is in the hands of foreign soldiers. Starting in the third week of April, more than 5,000 Chinese soldiers of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) have intruded into five points in Ladakh – four along the Galwan River, and one near the Pangong Lake.”

“In the Pangong Tso sector, Chinese troops continue to occupy the area up to Finger 4, which includes 8 kms of Indian-claimed territory between Finger 8 – which is the Indian version of the LAC – and Finger 4,” Shukla’s blog noted.

In the Galwan River sector, the PLA still occupies the area up to PP 15 and PP 17 and the heights overlooking the Galwan valley.

Also read-


  1. Every single map with the Army in Ladakh shows the LAC passing through Finger 8 at Pangong Tso. The Chinese are sitting eight kms to the west of it, have made bunkers and posts. So whose territory is it that they are in?
    Does Modi’s statement signal India is willing to live with China’s forcible change of the status quo in the Galwan Valley and at Lake Pangong? By occupying unoccupied areas, China has put a halt to India’s patrolling of those areas and built positions overlooking Indian defenses.

    1)Is Modi saying that the External Affairs Ministry statement about Chinese trying to build a structure on the Indian side of the LAC is false?
    2) Does the PM mean all land where Chinese troops are at present is their territory ?
    3) Did our soldiers die on Indian territory or Chinese territory?
    4) Why did MEA say that China had tried to “erect a structure” in Galwan on our side of LAC, hindered patrolling etc?
    5)Do the Chinese currently hold land that was previously patrolled by Indian troops?
    6)If there was no intrusion why are 20 soldiers dead?
    7)Did the Indian soldiers have firearms?
    8)Did the political and military leadership miss intelligence alerts?

    Jai Hind


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories

How Indian and Chinese troops fought at Galwan valley

By Syed Ali Mujtaba The Indian troops fight with PLA on Monday June 15, had claimed at least 23 soldiers’ lives and some 24 are...

Opposition puts Modi govt on mat for Chinese naked aggression in Ladakh

Opposition puts  Modi govt on mat for Chinese naked aggression in Ladakh. Govt must come out with authoritative statement on what happened at LAC. By...

34 Indian soldiers missing in Ladakh after India-China soldiers clashed, says a report

By Muslim Mirror Desk New Delhi ,June 16: After the face-off between India and China in Galwan Valley last night, “thirty-four Indian soldiers are also...

3 Indian Army men killed during face-off with Chinese soldiers

  NEW DELHI:Three Indian Army men, including an officer, were killed on Monday night during a violent face-off with Chinese Peoples Liberation Army troops at...
By Latheef Farook November 29 marks the day when the United Nations, under pressure from US, Britain and Europe, divided Palestine and created an artificial state for imported Jews in violation of all accepted norms , laws and moral principles. The...
Siddharthnagar : A temple in Uttar Pradesh’s Siddharthnagar district was ‘purified’ with ‘gangajal’ after a visit by a Muslim MLA of the Samajwadi Party. Doomariyaganj MLA Sayeda Khatoon had on Sunday visited the Samay Mata temple at the invitation of...
New Delhi : A court here has acquitted nine accused people of all charges, including rioting, vandalism, and arson, during the 2020 Delhi riots, saying they were entitled to the benefit of the doubt. Additional Sessions Judge Pulastya Pramachala was...
Srinagar : After it faced flak from a section of politicians, the Jammu and Kashmir Police on Tuesday defended booking under UAPA seven university students who had raised objectionable slogans after the Indian cricket team’s in the World Cup...
Varanasi : The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has sought three more weeks to submit the scientific survey report of the Gyanvapi mosque in Varanasi. The survey had concluded almost a month ago and the ASI had sought extra time...