Sohrabuddin case: Lawyers’ body moves Bombay HC against CBI not challenging Amit Shah’s discharge

The Bombay Lawyers Association, which filed the public interest litigation, termed as “illegal, arbitrary and malafide” the CBI’s decision not to challenge the December 30, 2014 order passed by a court here discharging Shah.

Mumbai: A city-based lawyers’ association today filed a PIL in the Bombay High Court against the CBI’s decision not to challenge a lower court order discharging BJP president Amit Shah in the Sohrabuddin Shaikh fake encounter case. The Bombay Lawyers Association, which filed the public interest litigation, termed as “illegal, arbitrary and malafide” the CBI’s decision not to challenge the December 30, 2014 order passed by a court here discharging Shah.

The PIL urged the high court to issue a direction to the CBI to file a revision application challenging the sessions court’s order discharging Shah.

The petitioner’s lawyer Ahmad Abidi said the plea would be mentioned before a division bench of justices S C Dharmadhikari and Bharti Dangre on January 22.

“The CBI is a premier investigating agency. It has public duty to observe the rule of law in its action but it has miserably failed,” the petition said.

It submitted that the trial court had similarly discharged two Rajasthan Police sub-inspectors, Himanshu Singh and Shyam Singh Charan, and senior Gujarat police officer N K Amin in the case.

“The petitioner has learnt that the CBI has challenged their discharge before the high court. This act of the CBI in challenging discharge of the accused persons on selective basis is arbitrary and unreasonable, rather malafide,” the petition said.

It also claimed that the Supreme Court, while transferring the trial in the case from Gujarat to Mumbai, had ordered that it be concluded expeditiously. “The Supreme Court had said the Administrative Committee of the high court would assign the case to a court where the trial may be concluded judiciously, in accordance with the law, and without any delay.

“The Administrative Committee would also ensure that the trial should be conducted from beginning to end by the same officer, the apex court had said in its order,” it said.

In a related development, another judge of the high court today issued notices to the CBI and the accused in the Sohrabuddin Shaikh case on two petitions filed by journalists against the trial court’s ban on the reporting the proceedings.

Justice Revati Mohite-Dere will hear the petitions on January 23. The trial court had issued the gag order after defence lawyers referred to “misreporting” about the death of judge B H Loya who had dealt with the case earlier, and raised security concerns.

The CBI today told the high court that its stand on the issue was “neutral”.

Gangster Sohrabuddin Shaikh, who the Gujarat police claimed was also a terrorist, was killed in an alleged fake encounter by the Gujarat and Rajasthan police in 2005. His wife Kausar Bi disappeared, and was alleged to have been eliminated by police. Shaikh’s associate Tulsi Prajapati was also later killed in an alleged fake encounter.

The CBI took over the probe in February 2010 and filed charge sheet in July the same year against 23 accused, including Amit Shah, who at that time was the minister of state for home in Gujarat.

The trial court, over a period of time, discharged several accused in the case, including Shah and three IPS officers.


Also read-


  1. In Hindi, we say, “Basi kadhi (a favorite veg dish) men ubal aaee,” man apna purana qatil hai”.”police or BHC/SC keya Pandit Misra jaisa Modi/Shah kee gandee siasat to na na umeed karega aur apna zid badelga hai”. Let us admit the damage to the Indian fabric of civilization done since 2002 under the supervision of Modi, i.e., just in 15 years has superseded by the “halla-balla” of The Muslim sultanates and British colonizers under Churchill, the Gandhi hater, combined. Enjoy Modiji (testosterone suppressed0 and Shahji (testosterone enhanced), ever ready to have booz and the 3-ltr sex


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories

Military officer staged Shopian ‘encounter’ for 20 lakh rupees

SRINAGAR — Jammu and Kashmir Police has charged an army captain of stage-managing the Amshipora (Shopian) encounter to get the reward money of Rs 20...

Kashmir: Bodies of labourers killed as ‘terrorists’ were exhumed

By Muslim Mirror Staff The bodies of the three labourers killed by the Indian Army, which called them terrorists but later admitted that there was...

Misused AFSPA in Kashmir encounter , Indian Army admits

  By Muslim Mirror Staff Srinagar, September 20: On July 18, Indian armed forces said they killed three unidentified terrorist in Amshipora village in Shopian ,...

Sohrabuddin-Prajapati killings: Special Court verdict rips CBI’s probe

Mumbai : The entire CBI investigation in the politically sensitive Sohrabuddin Shaikh-Tulsiram Prajapati and Kausar Bi's alleged encounter killings case was targeted "to act...

Muslim vendors prevented from doing business in Karnataka temple fair

Bengaluru: The Muslims traders have been allegedly debarred from installing their business units at a temple fair in Mangaluru city of Dakshina Kannada district...

Nawab Malik issue rocks Maharashtra assembly

Nagpur : Maharashtra assembly on Thursday witnessed ruckus on the first day of the winter session after former Maharashtra minister and NCP member Nawab...

Article 370 verdict: Omar Abdullah vows to ‘fight’ regardless of case outcome in SC

Kulgam : With the Supreme Court yet to pronounce its verdict on the revocation of Article 370 from Jammu and Kashmir, National Conference leader...

Putin says nothing can hinder development of Russian-Saudi relations

ISTANBUL : Russian President Vladimir Putin told Saudi Arabia’s ruler Wednesday that nothing can prevent the development of their countries’ relations. “While here in the...

Guterres invokes UN Charter to call for UNSC action on Gaza

United Nations : In a bid to push the paralysed Security Council to act on Gaza, Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Wednesday invoked a rarely...

24000 Madrassas under scrutiny in Uttar Pradesh for ‘receiving funds from abroad’

Approximately 24,000 madrassas in Uttar Pradesh have come under intense scrutiny as authorities investigate allegations of receiving funds from abroad. The focus of the...

We are Gau Mata country: Himanta on DMK MP’s comment

Guwahati : Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Wednesday said India is a “Gau Mata” country and asserted that there is no dispute...

‘Here to make it easier for Muslims in India to go to Makkah, Madinah”: Saudi Minister of Hajj

New Delhi : Saudi Minister of Haj and Umrah Tawfiq bin Fawzan Al-Rabiah on Wednesday said “We are here to make it easier for...

31 years after Babri Mosque demolition: Perpetrators rule India

By Shamsul Islam Criminal Hindutva perpetrators instead of being punished rule India The RSS-BJP government of India led by a seasoned RSS whole-timer, Narendra Modi has...

Indian Army Major dismissed for ‘ties with Pakistani intelligence operative’

An Indian Army Major, who was recently dismissed from service by the President in October, is alleged to have been in contact with a...

Postpone probe into madrasas: UP madrasa board to Yogi govt

Lucknow : Following the Uttar Pradesh government’s decision to initiate a probe into the availability of basic facilities and competent teachers at state-funded madrasas,...

Turkey, Qatar sign 12 agreements, issue joint declaration after high strategic committee meeting

DOHA, Qatar : Turkey and Qatar on Monday signed 12 cooperation agreements in various fields and the joint declaration of the 9th meeting of...

Anti-terror case: NIA searches in 5 J&K districts

Srinagar: The National Investigation Agency (NIA) on Tuesday carried out searches at several places in five districts of Kashmir valley as part of a...

Almost 1.9M Palestinian displaced across Gaza Strip since Oct. 7: UN

ISTANBUL : Almost 1.9 million people, or over 80% of the population, have been displaced across the Gaza Strip since Oct. 7, the UN...

Modi will become PM for third time: Badruddin Ajmal

Guwahati : All India United Democratic Front (AIUDF) chief, Badruddin Ajmal said that the BJP’s victory in the three state Assembly elections have proved...